As part of my Post-K Summer Reading Boot Camp:
This was a nice book but nothing special. I like that it’s trying to get kids into mysteries, using their problem solving, critical thinking, and powers of deduction/process of elimination skills. I also liked that it showed that if you want to solve a mystery, you have to “write stuff down”; Kayla and her friend Mason not only write down what they know but what they don’t know (an interesting concept). However, if the solve had been more interesting than simply a case of overlooking something, I would’ve liked it a bit better.
The story was told from the dog’s point-of-view, which was a good call; a children’s book should rarely be told from the parent’s point-of-view.
But the idea of a communal/classroom tooth pillow seems rather unsanitary–is this a thing now?
I didn’t like that this was divided into chapters because this is the kind of story that needs to be read in one sitting. Use a bookmark if you want a stopping point. Teaching a child to use a bookmark (rather than folding down the corner of a page or turning the book over so that it puts pressure on the spine) is a good habit to instill early on. Whenever I’m reviewing an adult book, I have multiple bookmarks handy, so I can refer back to certain passages.
The Case of the Lost Tooth is a paint-by-the-numbers book where the dots all look the same. Kayla needed a more interesting personality, though King is all dog. Captain Cat Obvious needed a bigger role, for he could’ve added a bit of spice to this overly sweet book. The tooth fairy could’ve also joined in the search but maybe kids–just like with Santa Claus–aren’t supposed to see the tooth fairy. However, the note under Kayla’s pillow was a nice touch.
Using the dog’s best sleuthing tool–his nose–King and Kayla solved this non-mystery. The moral of the story? Dig a little deeper–literally.
The illustrations were somewhat eighties (i.e. reminiscent of my childhood). The lack of background/negative space made it very readable, though ultimately, the visuals fell flat, and the story wasn’t compelling enough to make me want to read the other installments. This was too long for a read-aloud, but short and simple enough for early readers–a book my child would have to choose on her own for me to pick it up again.
Suggested activity: There are lots of children’s books that talk about the tooth fairy. However, if your child is old enough, you can also talk about how dogs help humans solve mysteries (e.g. find missing children–I would not get into finding corpses), help the blind navigate a seeing world, etc. Here is a good listicle outlining all the ways dogs improve the lives of humans. https://www.petfriendly.ca/articles/how-dogs-help-people.php